Lalai

White noise vs a fan A generated hiss, or the real thing

Many people who say they sleep with white noise really sleep with a fan. The two are close cousins but not the same: a fan is softer at the top and has a hum in it. Hear them side by side below.

White noise

Flat and bright: every frequency at once

Fan noise

The box fan that has worked since childhood

Both free to play here, one at a time, with no ads and nothing to sign up for. Set your volume low before you start.

On this page

    What a fan really sounds like

    A fan makes two sounds. The blades passing give a low hum at a steady pitch, and the air tumbling off them gives a broad rush. That rush is close to noise, but it isn’t white: on our measurements it is strongest from about 1 to 4 kHz and falls away almost completely above 6 kHz.

    White noise keeps rising all the way to the top of the range. That is the difference you hear: a fan is a soft whir, and white noise has a crisp edge a fan doesn’t.

    The practical differences

    A fan also moves air, which some people want and some don’t, and it can dry out eyes and sinuses over a night. It uses power, can rattle as it ages, and its sound changes with the speed setting. A recording or a generated noise stays exactly the same every night.

    If you are used to a fan but don’t want the draught, a fan recording gives you the sound without the air. If you find the fan’s hum noticeable, white or pink noise has no pitch in it at all.

    Measured side by side

    We measured both loops exactly as they play on this page.

    0-10-20-30-40White noise, 63 Hz: -18.5 dBA box fan, 63 Hz: -17.5 dB63White noise, 125 Hz: -14.1 dBA box fan, 125 Hz: -3.3 dB125White noise, 250 Hz: -11 dBA box fan, 250 Hz: -6.9 dB250White noise, 500 Hz: -8.3 dBA box fan, 500 Hz: -10 dB500White noise, 1 kHz: -5.6 dBA box fan, 1 kHz: -1 dB1kWhite noise, 2 kHz: -2.9 dBA box fan, 2 kHz: -0.4 dB2kWhite noise, 4 kHz: -0.6 dBA box fan, 4 kHz: 0 dB4kWhite noise, 8 kHz: 0 dBA box fan, 8 kHz: below −40 dB8kWhite noise, 16 kHz: -3.9 dBA box fan, 16 kHz: below −40 dB16k
    Level in each octave band, each relative to its own loudest band (0 dB).

    White noise A box fan

    White noiseA box fan
    Peaks around8 kHz4 kHz
    Balance point5.6 kHz1.9 kHz
    Moves by0.8 dB0.9 dB
    MadeGeneratedRecorded
    In the appSubscriptionFree
    The numbers
    Octave bandWhite noiseA box fan
    63 Hz-18.5 dB-17.5 dB
    125 Hz-14.1 dB-3.3 dB
    250 Hz-11 dB-6.9 dB
    500 Hz-8.3 dB-10 dB
    1 kHz-5.6 dB-1 dB
    2 kHz-2.9 dB-0.4 dB
    4 kHz-0.6 dB0 dB
    8 kHz0 dBbelow −60
    16 kHz-3.9 dBbelow −60

    Which to choose

    If you wantTryBecause
    The familiar sound of homeA box fanA real fan, hum and all.
    No pitch or hum at allWhite noisePure, even noise.
    A softer top endA box fanIt falls away above 6 kHz.
    Covering high, sharp soundsWhite noiseStrong all the way up.

    Or play them together in the mixer.

    Questions

    Is a fan the same as white noise?

    Not exactly. A fan makes a broad rush of air that is similar to noise, plus a low hum from the blades. Measured, it has much less energy at the very top than white noise, which is why it sounds softer.

    All night, with the screen off. A browser tab stops when your phone locks. In Lalai the sound keeps playing, fades out on a timer, and you can layer up to five of 198 sounds with music underneath. The mixer, the timer and a free sound in every category are free for good.

    Download on the App Store

    Listening safely

    Start with your volume low, keep the phone off the pillow, and let the timer fade the sound out. Our listening notes say more.

    Lalai is for relaxation and enjoyment. We don’t claim that this or any sound changes how you sleep, and if poor sleep goes on for weeks, please see a doctor. More on protecting your hearing.

    More comparisons

    See every noise colour in the colours of noise, or browse all 50 night sounds.